Tromell, Seymour's Butler

The value of X is determined only once, as Tromell's last ability resolves. To determine that value, look at the nontoken creatures you control and count each one that entered this turn. It doesn't matter if they were creatures when they entered or who controlled them when they entered.

Wotc — June 06, 2025

You don't have to choose every permanent or player that has a counter—only the ones you want to add counters to. Since "any number" includes zero, you don't have to choose any permanents at all, and you don't have to choose any players at all.

Wotc — June 06, 2025

Players can respond to a spell or ability whose effect includes proliferating. Once that spell or ability starts to resolve, however, and its controller chooses which permanents and players will get new counters, it's too late for anyone to respond.

Wotc — June 06, 2025

While proliferating multiple times, players can't respond between proliferating the first time and proliferating the second time, and so on.

Wotc — June 06, 2025

If you proliferate multiple times, you don't have to choose the same set of players and/or permanents to get additional counters each time.

Wotc — June 06, 2025

When you proliferate, you can choose any permanent that has a counter, including ones controlled by opponents. You can choose any player who has a counter, including opponents. You can't choose cards in any zone other than the battlefield, even if they have counters on them.

Wotc — June 06, 2025

If a player or permanent has more than one kind of counter on it, and you choose for it to get additional counters, it must get one of each kind of counter it already has. You can't have it get just one kind of counter it already has and not the others.

Wotc — June 06, 2025